Firstly a note on "what's attractive?" ...
The real key to being attractive is a good happy attitude and personality. I'd say it's 90% or more of it! We find people to be beautiful and attractive because of the good energy they project. That makes us feel good. That's what attracts us to those people.
We all choose with each moment to project either good or bad energy.
People project that attractive energy when they are at peace with and accepting of themselves.
Someone might have the most classic physical beauty but if they've got a bad attitude, they are not attractive.
I've known many "good looking" people (by current social standards) who are utterly repulsive because of their bad attitudes.
The terrible mistake to make is (like I did for years) to believe "I am not attractive because of physical aspect XYZ". That's a guaranteed formula for misery.
In contrast, accept yourself, do what you can to make the most of what you have and with that confidence you'll beam good energy and be most attractive.
The most attractive thing is a happy face.
When you are thus attractive the people who will then try to drag you down (with jabs like "OMG she's got hair there!") are the ones who are miserable in themselves and who are jealous of your evident contentment. There are many people who are very low down on the scale of emotional development.
IMHO rather then free themselves from their own mental prisons, from the self-imposed limits that make them unhappy, many people try to imprison those who have broken free. So be mindful of that and don't fall prey to their attempts to imprison you too, to sabotage your happiness.
On another note....
There certainly are many people who find women (and men) with body hair attractive. As a male, I think one of the absolute cutest things on a woman is a certain amount of hair on forearms, sideburn area and top lip etc. I find a body that has a "down" and some darker hairs on it is far more attractive than one without.
I've gone out with women of all types and some have been quite hairy (arms, legs, tummy, facial down etc.) and I found them very beautiful as did other people in general... Overall not because of the presence or absence of any physical features, but as explained above, because they were attractive as people, with a joyful twinkle in their eye.
It used to sadden me a bit that my wife shaves down below but I grew to appreciate it and I respect her preference

It's really only been the last 15-20 years that removing so much hair has been the in thing to conform with.
However, I suspect it may be a runaway train ... peer group pressure to conform ... just look at how so many men now (including myself) are doing things to reduce/remove hair ... as much as we want to resist it and change mass public opinion, I don't know if we ever can. Because mass public opinion is largely driven by "belonging, following the herd, doing what others do, conforming" etc.
Though I do see some signs that it's swinging back a bit, that some body hair is back in favour.
Only time will tell.
In the meantime, I recommend choose to be happy now, make the most of what you've got, focus on the positive and love every moment.
:-)